Is it in the Punctuation; the Exclamation Point or the Question Mark?
“I have heard of You by the hearing of the ear, But now my eye sees You.” Job 42:5
Just over a month ago my son went out one evening to a concert. None of his buddies were available but he decided he would just go alone. The band he went to see had an opening act that was playing when he got there. He sensed immediately that there was something not right. But, it was a light crowd so he moved up to the front and began taking a few pictures.
From out of nowhere, there came a crushing blow to the side of his head. He went down into a ball as six guys jumped on him, pummeling him with punches and kicks. When they stopped, he was taken by ambulance to the hospital. I was away but my wife got the call all parents fear. She rushed to the hospital to find him with black eyes, lumps all over his head, beaten and bloodied, with broken bones that would require surgery.
Now, more than a month later, we thank God that the physical damage is healing. But, the emotional and spiritual wounds linger. The shocking randomness of the violence continues to haunt him. The confusion circles in his head. Why did these guys do this? What did I do to deserve it? And the inevitable – Why me?
Pastor Stephen J (not to be confused with Pastor Steve) gave an absolutely awesome message a few Sunday’s ago about the goodness and righteousness of God in the midst of our trials. I agree with all of it 100%. However, there was one thing in his message that I have had some different thoughts about. It has to do with the issue of asking “Why?” about the trials we go through.
The reaction of “Why me!” to our trials is almost always raised with a major dose of either cynicism or a moralism. We reject God for allowing or imposing the trial on us or we determine that God is punishing us for some crime and we must win back His favor. Mostly, like Job, we are certain we don’t deserve it.
Most people cry out when bad things happen, “Why me God!” In most cases it is not a genuine question but a declarative statement using an exclamation point rather than a question mark. We are saying, “This is not fair!” or “I don’t like this!” or “Why have you done this to me! I have done nothing to deserve this!” or “You’re being mean. Just stop already!”
No, God does not owe us an explanation and if demanding an answer from God is all we are after then it is unlikely to lead us to where God wants to take us. Ultimately, as Christ-followers, do we need to know the reason for the bad things that happen to us? Isn’t it enough to be certain of God’s love and his majesty to know that He is in control? I would say that most Christians consider this to be the appropriate response – don’t ask, but trust. However, is this what God intends for us in our relationship with Him? Is there actually a right way to ask the question?
In the book of Job, Job repeatedly declares the unfairness of it all and according to the story there seems no good reason he deserves all the terrible trials other than God proving a point to Satan.
I find Job a challenging read. But, what I do grasp is that through most of the book, Job believes that what God is allowing is beyond his understanding. He’s sorting through all the voices and the many opinions of men but mostly declaring that He (and we) can’t know what God is doing. Is that true?


I wonder – what is the difference between the weak, little faith that led to the failure of the disciples and the minuscule mustard seed faith that Jesus declares can move mountains?